corpus rubenianum, vol. xv, gregory martin, rubens. the ceiling decoration of the banqueting hall, london 2005, p. 168-171: as „copy“ of no. 3b, see also "copy" of no. 3c (cr/martin 2005 julius von held, the oil sketches of peter paul rubens. a critical catalogue, vol. ii, princeton 1980, p. 195: as „copy“ no. 2 of cat. no. 130, with a reference to the exhibition in budapest in 1946; cr/martin 2005 wrongly refers this exhibition to no. 3b (academy of fine arts, vienna (held 1980 old masters in hungarian private collections, exhibition catalogue, museum of fine arts, budapest 1946, no. 82, ill.: according to held 1980; cr/martin 2005 refers this exhibition to no. 3b (budapest 1946 sedelmeyer gallery, exhibition catalogue, fifth series of 100 paintings by old masters, paris 1899, p. 54, no. 44, ill. (sedelmeyer 1899 cf. max rooses, l'oeuvre de p. p. rubens. histoire et description de ses tableaux et dessins, vol. 3, antwerpen 1890, p. 284: reference to the modello with horion/reynolds/baillie-provenance cf. d'hulst, roger-a., olieverfschetsen von rubens uit nederlands en belgisch openbaar bezit, amsterdam 1968, p. 105 cf. john smith, a catalogue raisonné of the works of the most eminent dutch, flemish, and french painters: peter paul rubens, part ii, london 1830, p. 199, no. 717: dimensions 26 x 21 in. = 66 x 53,3, c = canvas (smith 1830